DemandHunt 世界コミュニティの機会レーダー
日本語
開発ツール・SaaS Hacker News · 2022-05-25

エンタープライズ級・自ホスト可能なZoomオープンソース代替は実在するのか?

Why is there no enterprise-grade open-source Zoom alternative?

30秒でわかる要約
  • 誰がHacker News · 2022-05-25 · 41 賛成 · 34 返信
  • 何を求めているかエンタープライズ級・自ホスト可能なZoomオープンソース代替は実在するのか?
  • 何を作れるかAn enterprise wrapper over LiveKit/Jitsi: recording archive, watermarks, SSO, managed ops.

元スレッドの発言

“They like to self-host everything, and are wary of using outside services… We've set up Jitsi.”

— Hacker News · 2022-05-25 · news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31504008…

背景と課題

痛みのポイント

政府・医療・金融は完全プライベート化を求めますが、オープンソースは安定性・録画・大規模配信で一歩及びません。

プロダクトの切り口

何を作れるか

An enterprise wrapper over LiveKit/Jitsi: recording archive, watermarks, SSO, managed ops.

検証のしかた

  1. スレッドの返信をすべて読み、繰り返し出てくる具体的な場面を書き出します。繰り返しこそ需要の密度です。
  2. 「video calls / self-hosted」関連の既存ツールを調べ、どの一部分しかカバーしていないかを確認します。
  3. 一言ランディングページを作り、Hacker News に投稿して価格を聞く人が現れるか見ます。

既存の選択肢

Jitsi, LiveKit, BigBlueButton

スレッドの声 · 人気コメント

人気コメントは機械翻訳です。原文は元スレッドで確認できます。

I'd point to this related question. "Chat" services of various kinds have been around on the internet since the 1990s, the one thing that they all have in common is that they burn out. For instance there was CUSeeMe, Paltalk, Tivejo, AOL Instant Messenger, ICQ, Skype, WebEx, Facebook Messenger, and many others. Google alone has made 11. Some of them are still around, but there's a general pattern that a company does the work to create an application but doesn't do the work to keep it up. Then some new thing comes along, gets popular for a while, then deteriorates. Unless Zoom breaks the patter

— PaulHoule

What you are looking for is BigBlueButton: https://bigbluebutton.org/ It is targetting the virtual classroom market but it does general videoconferencing just right.

— prmoustache

Sorry, I must be a luddite. I don't get the video conferencing craze. In most cases, I see little real, added value in a live video feed. What I find more generally useful is simple desktop/screen sharing with audio (i.e. GotoMeeting, TeamViewer) If you must see the participants, allow a photo/avatar. Watching real lips moving in a stuttered video is quite chic and nouveau and all ... it's nice with family ... but it doesn't really add much value in a typical business setting IMO. As with most things, there are exceptions but I use desktop sharing way more often.

— jqpabc123
元スレッドを開く

同じ課題の他のスレッド

関連する機会