DemandHunt 海外社區機會雷達
繁中
獨立開發與工具 Hacker News · 2022-05-25

企業級、可私有化的 Zoom 開源替代到底存不存在?

Why is there no enterprise-grade open-source Zoom alternative?

30 秒速覽
  • 誰在提Hacker News · 2022-05-25 · 41 贊 · 34 評
  • 想要什麼企業級、可私有化的 Zoom 開源替代到底存不存在?
  • 能做成什麼Jitsi/LiveKit 之上的企業封裝:錄製歸檔、合規水印、SSO、運維託管,按年授權。

原帖原話

“They like to self-host everything, and are wary of using outside services… We've set up Jitsi.”

“有個客戶想把 Zoom 換掉,他們喜歡一切自建、對第三方服務很警惕。我們幫他們自建郵件、GitLab、Mattermost,Jitsi 也搭了,但還是不夠。”

— Hacker News · 2022-05-25 · news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31504008…

需求背景與痛點

痛在哪

政企、醫療、金融必須私有化,但開源方案在穩定性、錄製、大規模旁路上都差一截。

可以做成什麼

能做成什麼

Jitsi/LiveKit 之上的企業封裝:錄製歸檔、合規水印、SSO、運維託管,按年授權。

怎麼驗證它

  1. 讀完原帖的評論區,把重複出現的具體場景記下來——重複次數就是需求的密度。
  2. 搜索「視頻會議 / 私有化」相關的現有工具,確認它們只覆蓋了哪一環。
  3. 用一句話落地頁,投回 Hacker News 或同類社群,看有沒有人主動問價格。

已有方案與差異

Jitsi、LiveKit、BigBlueButton

社區原聲 · 熱門評論

熱門評論由機器翻譯為中文,點擊原帖核對原意。

I'd point to this related question. "Chat" services of various kinds have been around on the internet since the 1990s, the one thing that they all have in common is that they burn out. For instance there was CUSeeMe, Paltalk, Tivejo, AOL Instant Messenger, ICQ, Skype, WebEx, Facebook Messenger, and many others. Google alone has made 11. Some of them are still around, but there's a general pattern that a company does the work to create an application but doesn't do the work to keep it up. Then some new thing comes along, gets popular for a while, then deteriorates. Unless Zoom breaks the patter

— PaulHoule

What you are looking for is BigBlueButton: https://bigbluebutton.org/ It is targetting the virtual classroom market but it does general videoconferencing just right.

— prmoustache

Sorry, I must be a luddite. I don't get the video conferencing craze. In most cases, I see little real, added value in a live video feed. What I find more generally useful is simple desktop/screen sharing with audio (i.e. GotoMeeting, TeamViewer) If you must see the participants, allow a photo/avatar. Watching real lips moving in a stuttered video is quite chic and nouveau and all ... it's nice with family ... but it doesn't really add much value in a typical business setting IMO. As with most things, there are exceptions but I use desktop sharing way more often.

— jqpabc123
打開原帖核對

同一痛點的其他討論

相關機會