개발 도구·micro-SaaS Hacker News · 2022-05-25

기업급 자체 호스팅 가능한 Zoom 오픈소스 대안은 정말 존재하는가?

Why is there no enterprise-grade open-source Zoom alternative?

30초 요약

누가Hacker News · 2022-05-25 · 추천 41 · 댓글 34
무엇을 원하는가기업급 자체 호스팅 가능한 Zoom 오픈소스 대안은 정말 존재하는가?
무엇을 만들 수 있나An enterprise wrapper over LiveKit/Jitsi: recording archive, watermarks, SSO, managed ops.

원글 발언

“They like to self-host everything, and are wary of using outside services… We've set up Jitsi.”
— Hacker News · 2022-05-25 · news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31504008…

배경과 문제

아픈 지점

정부·의료·금융은 완전 사내 구축을 원하지만 오픈소스는 안정성, 녹화, 대규모 시청에서 한 발 미칩니다.

제품 방향

무엇을 만들 수 있나

An enterprise wrapper over LiveKit/Jitsi: recording archive, watermarks, SSO, managed ops.

검증 방법

원글의 댓글을 끝까지 읽고 반복되는 구체적 상황을 적어 두세요. 반복이 곧 수요의 밀도입니다.
"video calls / self-hosted" 관련 기존 도구를 검색해 어느 한 단계만 커버하는지 확인합니다.
한 줄 랜딩 페이지를 만들어 Hacker News에 공유하고 가격을 묻는 사람이 나타나는지 봅니다.

기존 대안

Jitsi, LiveKit, BigBlueButton

스레드의 목소리 · 인기 댓글

I'd point to this related question. "Chat" services of various kinds have been around on the internet since the 1990s, the one thing that they all have in common is that they burn out. For instance there was CUSeeMe, Paltalk, Tivejo, AOL Instant Messenger, ICQ, Skype, WebEx, Facebook Messenger, and many others. Google alone has made 11. Some of them are still around, but there's a general pattern that a company does the work to create an application but doesn't do the work to keep it up. Then some new thing comes along, gets popular for a while, then deteriorates. Unless Zoom breaks the patter

— PaulHoule

What you are looking for is BigBlueButton: https://bigbluebutton.org/ It is targetting the virtual classroom market but it does general videoconferencing just right.

— prmoustache

Sorry, I must be a luddite. I don't get the video conferencing craze. In most cases, I see little real, added value in a live video feed. What I find more generally useful is simple desktop/screen sharing with audio (i.e. GotoMeeting, TeamViewer) If you must see the participants, allow a photo/avatar. Watching real lips moving in a stuttered video is quite chic and nouveau and all ... it's nice with family ... but it doesn't really add much value in a typical business setting IMO. As with most things, there are exceptions but I use desktop sharing way more often.

— jqpabc123

원글 열기

같은 문제의 다른 스레드

미디어·창작 (3)