DemandHunt 글로벌 커뮤니티 기회 레이더
한국어
개발 도구·micro-SaaS Hacker News · 2022-08-02

웹 요소에 직접 댓글을 달고 싶다: '검사'에 Google 댓글을 붙인 듯한 제품

A product that lets you comment on HTML elements and share it with your org

30초 요약
  • 누가Hacker News · 2022-08-02 · 추천 91 · 댓글 59
  • 무엇을 원하는가웹 요소에 직접 댓글을 달고 싶다: '검사'에 Google 댓글을 붙인 듯한 제품
  • 무엇을 만들 수 있나Element-level annotation for web apps, with state capture and Jira/Linear sync.

원글 발언

“Think google comments connected to Inspect Element in chrome that can be shared with an organization.”

— Hacker News · 2022-08-02 · news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32315035…

배경과 문제

아픈 지점

디자인 검수는 스크린샷 + 문자 설명에 의존해 위치를 전달하기 어렵고, 개발자는 요소를 반복해서 찾아야 합니다.

제품 방향

무엇을 만들 수 있나

Element-level annotation for web apps, with state capture and Jira/Linear sync.

검증 방법

  1. 원글의 댓글을 끝까지 읽고 반복되는 구체적 상황을 적어 두세요. 반복이 곧 수요의 밀도입니다.
  2. "design review / annotation" 관련 기존 도구를 검색해 어느 한 단계만 커버하는지 확인합니다.
  3. 한 줄 랜딩 페이지를 만들어 Hacker News에 공유하고 가격을 묻는 사람이 나타나는지 봅니다.

기존 대안

Marker.io, BugHerd, Pastel

스레드의 목소리 · 인기 댓글

How is this your biggest problem? Emailing an annotated screenshot or attaching to a JIRA seems better because it's more consistent and blends with other processes. What should happen when webpages content changes or goes defunct? Now you're also creating an archive.org... and on and on. Don't get stuck and sink your time into a local maxima. Maybe you'll find a market [of fools] willing to invest time into this exact locally optimal solution, but I predict it will be disappointingly small. The problem it solves isn't broadly substantial enough to warrant a specialized solution. Only one way t

— metadat

Actually, this an ecosystem of visual bug reporting tools that already exists and it's very useful when your other testers/stakeholders are time constrained. These days people talk about user experience, well, this is the equivalent of that for tester experience. It makes it a lot easier to submit useful big reports. When you mandate jira (which is slow even on its fastest day) you then a big report from a 2 second click in an on page tool to like a 10 minute process, filling out all the fields, cropping the screenshot, copying over the url and console log and any network errors and all that.

— solardev

What if the element moves or is replaced in the next design iteration ? I’m not sure you want to be merging and splitting tickets on individual DOM elements to keep the comment history sane.. Though I would be interested in tooling that allows clients to simply create issues by clicking an element and then saving full context (dom, screenshot, url, form state, browser and session) with that issue. Something important is too often missing from a bug report. But then the problem is getting the client to actually use that tool.

— unilynx
원글 열기

같은 문제의 다른 스레드

관련 기회