DemandHunt 世界コミュニティの機会レーダー
日本語
生活・健康・ハード Hacker News · 2022-01-28

プログラマがRSIになり、それでもPCの音声操作は頼れない

RSI makes typing impossible, yet PC voice control is still unreliable

30秒でわかる要約
  • 誰がHacker News · 2022-01-28 · 90 賛成 · 119 返信
  • 何を求めているかプログラマがRSIになり、それでもPCの音声操作は頼れない
  • 何を作れるかA voice control layer that addresses UI elements and coding macros, sold against accessibility budgets.

元スレッドの発言

“RSI prevents me from writing code and doing graphic design through the usual keyboard and mouse inputs.”

— Hacker News · 2022-01-28 · news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30117383…

背景と課題

痛みのポイント

アクセシビリティとしての音声操作は需要も支払い意欲も本物なのに、既存ツールは「書き取り」のままでUIを理解しません。

プロダクトの切り口

何を作れるか

A voice control layer that addresses UI elements and coding macros, sold against accessibility budgets.

検証のしかた

  1. スレッドの返信をすべて読み、繰り返し出てくる具体的な場面を書き出します。繰り返しこそ需要の密度です。
  2. 「accessibility / voice」関連の既存ツールを調べ、どの一部分しかカバーしていないかを確認します。
  3. 一言ランディングページを作り、Hacker News に投稿して価格を聞く人が現れるか見ます。

既存の選択肢

Dragon, Talon Voice, Voice Control (macOS)

スレッドの声 · 人気コメント

Speech models today can mine the entire corpus of published conversation and return the most likely response to a given statement. That's not how we converse. Every relationship you have is a little model in your brain that we call a person's "personality." Every one talks differently, has different frames of reference, uses different codes of language, different assumptions. Cutting edge speech models work perfectly for the perfectly average speaker, but that person does not exist! The farther we stray from the mean, the more alienating these speech models become.

— ipnon

I have massive issues with speech recognition software. It doesn't work for me in either english or spanish. Statements like "google and siri are so advanced now" feel like people are collectively pranking me. That said, I too have wondered why we don't have speech control for computers or at least appliances. You don't need to parse all language. Just a standard set of primitives like you'd find on a remote should be way easier to recognize and can even be selected for their ease of parsing. Simple things like on, off, next, back, louder, etc.

— cptaj

An interesting project: Automatically convert a terminal commands `--help` page to a speech model. Run that over $PATH, then you never have to type again!

— ipnon
元スレッドを開く

同じ課題の他のスレッド

関連する機会